Non-Filer Cases

Non-Filer Cases and Failure to File Charges

How non-filer cases start, when IRS Criminal Investigation steps in, and what to do first.

A non-filer case begins when the IRS concludes that a person or business was required to file a federal tax return and did not. Most are resolved on the civil side, with late returns, penalties, and a payment arrangement. Some are not. Willfully failing to file is a federal crime, and IRS Criminal Investigation (IRS CI) refers non-filer cases to the Department of Justice for prosecution.

Whiteford's tax controversy attorneys represent non-filers on both tracks, from the first IRS notice through a criminal investigation.

If you have unfiled returns, or you have received a summons or subpoena, speak with Michael March and our team before you file anything or answer any questions.

Which unfiled returns lead to non-filer cases

A non-filer case follows the return that is missing. The exposure is different for individual, business, and employment tax returns, and so is the way back into compliance.

Individual returns: Forms 1040 and 1040-NR

The IRS finds individual non-filers by matching Forms W-2, 1099, and K-1 against the returns it has on file. When income is reported and no return appears, the IRS sends notices. It can then prepare a substitute for return under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) § 6020(b), which assesses tax without the deductions and credits you could have claimed.

The failure-to-file penalty adds 5% of the unpaid tax for each month the return is late, up to 25%. There is no time limit on assessing tax for a year in which no return was filed. Our page on unfiled tax returns explains how individuals get current.

Business returns: Forms 1120, 1120-S, and 1065

A C corporation that does not file Form 1120 faces the same tax-based penalty as an individual. S corporations and partnerships usually owe no tax at the entity level, so their penalty is charged per owner. For returns due in 2026, it is $255 per shareholder or partner for each month the return is late, for up to 12 months.

A missing Form 1120-S or Form 1065 also means no Schedules K-1 for the owners. Without a K-1, a shareholder or partner cannot file an accurate personal return. One unfiled business return can put every owner out of compliance.

Employment tax returns: Form 941

Employers report withheld income tax, Social Security tax, and Medicare tax each quarter on Form 941. The IRS treats unfiled Forms 941 more seriously than most missing returns, because the withheld amounts are held in trust for the government.

On the civil side, owners and officers who were responsible for the taxes can be held personally liable through the trust fund recovery penalty. On the criminal side, willfully failing to pay over taxes withheld from employees is a felony.

Form 1040-NR non-filers and immigration status

Nonresident aliens with U.S. income file Form 1040-NR. For them, not filing carries two consequences that U.S. citizens do not face.

The first is a tax cost. Under Treasury Regulation § 1.874-1, a nonresident generally loses the right to claim deductions and credits unless the return is filed within 16 months of its due date. The window can close sooner if the IRS sends a notice first. The IRS can waive the deadline for a filer who acted reasonably and in good faith.

The second is the immigration record. An applicant for naturalization must show good moral character, and a failure to file required tax returns can count against that showing. A lawful permanent resident who claims nonresident status on a tax return, or who does not file for that reason, raises a presumption of having abandoned permanent residence.

A conviction for tax evasion, or for a tax offense involving fraud, with a loss above $10,000 can be a ground for removal. A failure to file conviction by itself is a misdemeanor and is not in that category.

We work alongside your immigration counsel when a tax problem and an immigration filing overlap.

Can you go to jail for not filing taxes?

Yes, when the failure is willful. Willful means you knew the law required you to file and you chose not to. A good-faith misunderstanding of the law is not willful. Lacking the money to pay is not a defense to failing to file.

Three statutes cover most non-filer prosecutions:

StatuteConductClassificationMaximum prison term
IRC § 7203Willfully failing to file a return, pay tax, keep records, or supply informationMisdemeanor1 year per count
IRC § 7202Willfully failing to collect, truthfully account for, and pay over withheld employment taxesFelony5 years per count
IRC § 7204Willfully failing to furnish Forms W-2 to employees, or furnishing false onesMisdemeanor1 year per count

Prosecutors typically charge each unfiled year or quarter as a separate count, and fines and the costs of prosecution can be added to any sentence. For a failure to file charge under § 7203, the government generally has six years from the return's due date to bring the case. Courts have generally applied the same six-year period to § 7202.

Section 7202 applies when an employer willfully fails to collect, or to truthfully account for and pay over, taxes withheld from employees. Unfiled or false Forms 941 are often the evidence of that failure, but the offense turns on the unpaid trust fund taxes, not on the missing return. A willful failure to file Form 941 is itself a § 7203 offense. Section 7204 is a separate and less common charge that covers the Forms W-2 an employer must give its employees.

A non-filer case can also be charged as felony tax evasion under IRC § 7201. That happens when the failure to file is joined by an affirmative act of concealment, such as dealing in cash to avoid records, holding assets in other names, or lying to an agent. Our pages on tax evasion and employment tax fraud cover those charges.

How a non-filer case becomes a criminal investigation

Most non-filer cases start on the civil side, with notices, a substitute for return, or a revenue officer assigned to secure the missing returns. When a civil employee sees firm signs of fraud, the employee suspends the civil work and refers the case to IRS CI. IRS CI also opens cases on its own from informants, bank reports, and other investigations.

The facts that move a case are familiar: several unfiled years, substantial income, a history of filing that shows you knew the requirement, a cash business, or false statements to the IRS. Civil contact that stops without explanation can be a sign that a referral has been made.

IRS summonses and grand jury subpoenas

For most people, the first sign of a criminal case is a summons or a subpoena. It may be served on you, or on your bank, your accountant, your employees, or your customers. The two are different instruments.

An IRS summons is issued by the IRS itself under IRC § 7602. A special agent can issue one for records or testimony without going to a judge. If the recipient does not comply, the government asks the U.S. district court where that person lives or is found to enforce it.

A grand jury subpoena is issued under the authority of a U.S. district court at the request of a federal prosecutor. It comes from the district where the grand jury is investigating, and it means the Department of Justice is already involved. Once the IRS refers a case to the Justice Department, it can no longer issue its own summonses for that taxpayer, and the grand jury takes over.

A failure to file charge can generally be brought where you lived or where the return should have been filed. You can ask to be tried in your home district.

Neither one should be ignored, and neither should be answered without counsel. Our page on IRS special agent investigations explains what to do when an agent makes contact.

From IRS CI to the Department of Justice

IRS CI special agents build a non-filer case through witness testimony, documents, and tax returns. When the investigation is complete, IRS CI recommends prosecution or closes the case. A recommendation is reviewed inside the IRS and then referred to the Department of Justice, where prosecutors decide whether to bring charges. Charges are filed in U.S. district court.

The National Fraud Enforcement Division

The office that receives those referrals has changed. For decades, the Justice Department's Tax Division authorized nearly every federal criminal tax prosecution. The Tax Division ceased to exist as a separate office in late 2025, and its civil work moved to the Department's Civil Division.

The Justice Department created the National Fraud Enforcement Division in April 2026. A final rule effective August 24, 2026 assigned the Division all criminal proceedings arising under the internal revenue laws. A federal tax prosecution still needs centralized approval, and that approval now comes from the Division. The Department has said it expects the Division to reach about 500 attorneys and staff, including former Tax Division prosecutors. Its leadership can convene grand juries in any district.

The Division's published priorities emphasize promoters of tax schemes and fraud against federal programs. Non-filer cases remain within its authority. Sections 7202 and 7203 are unchanged, and IRS CI still lists non-filer enforcement and employment tax enforcement among its program areas. Prosecutors in a fraud division can also pair tax counts with wire fraud or money laundering charges, which carry longer sentences.

Getting into compliance before the government contacts you

The strongest position is to act before the IRS does. If the non-filing was not willful, the usual course is to file the delinquent returns. IRS policy generally calls for six years of returns, although the IRS can ask for more or accept fewer.

If the non-filing was willful, the IRS Voluntary Disclosure Practice may be the better route. IRS CI runs the program. You apply on Form 14457, make a truthful and complete disclosure, cooperate with the IRS in determining what you owe, and pay or arrange to pay the tax, interest, and penalties. A disclosure is not a promise of immunity from prosecution, but the IRS states that prosecution may not be recommended.

A disclosure has to be timely. It must reach the IRS before the IRS has started a civil examination or criminal investigation, and before the IRS has received information about your noncompliance from a third party. The practice is limited to income from legal sources.

Once IRS CI is involved, the decision changes. The offense of failing to file is complete when the due date passes, so a return filed after an agent's visit does not undo it. The figures on that return are your own statements. Whether and when to file becomes a legal decision to make with counsel.

What to do if you receive a summons or subpoena

  • Do not ignore it. Note who issued it, what it asks for, and the response date.
  • Do not destroy, alter, or backdate records. Obstruction can be easier for the government to prove than the tax offense.
  • Do not sit for an interview with a special agent on your own. You can tell the agent that your attorney will be in touch.
  • Do not ask your accountant or return preparer to respond for you. The tax practitioner privilege does not apply in criminal matters, and your preparer may be a witness.
  • Do not file late or amended returns until counsel has reviewed them.

Why Whiteford

A non-filer case can move between the civil and criminal sides of the IRS, and each side calls for different handling. Whiteford's tax controversy group works on both.

Michael March, Partner and Co-Chair of Whiteford's Tax Section, has defended criminal tax matters involving tax evasion, false returns, and payroll taxes. He has also handled civil controversies through IRS administrative proceedings and the U.S. Tax Court, including matters with parallel civil and criminal investigations. That work has been before federal district courts in Maryland, Virginia, West Virginia, Delaware, Florida, and the District of Columbia.

When we take on a non-filer matter, we take over communications with the IRS and its agents. We determine whether the case is civil or criminal and which years and forms are exposed. Where records need to be rebuilt, we retain forensic accountants so that their work is done under the attorney's direction. IRS and IRS CI matters are federal, so we represent clients before the agency wherever they live.

Talk to a Whiteford tax attorney about unfiled returns

If an agent has contacted you, contact us before you call the agent back. If no one has contacted you yet, this is the point at which you have the most options.

It helps to have these ready:

  • Any IRS notices, and any summons or subpoena, with the date each arrived
  • A list of the years or quarters and the forms that were not filed
  • The names of anyone the IRS has already contacted, such as your bank or accountant
  • Your most recent filed returns

We will tell you where the case stands, what the exposure is, and what to do first.

Frequently asked questions

Is it illegal to not file taxes?
Yes, if you were required to file. Whether you must file depends on your income, filing status, and the type of entity. Failing to file a required return brings civil penalties in every case. It becomes a crime under IRC § 7203 when the failure is willful.
How many years can the IRS go back on unfiled returns?
For civil purposes there is no limit, because the time to assess tax does not start until a return is filed. In practice the IRS generally asks for the last six years. For criminal purposes the government generally has six years from each return's due date to bring charges.
Will filing my late returns now stop a criminal investigation?
It depends on timing. Filing before the IRS contacts you, or making a voluntary disclosure, is usually the strongest protection available. Filing after IRS CI has opened an investigation does not undo the offense, and the returns can be used as evidence. Get advice before you file.
What is the difference between an IRS summons and a grand jury subpoena?
The IRS issues a summons on its own authority and needs a court only to enforce it. A grand jury subpoena is issued under a federal court's authority at a prosecutor's request. A summons from a special agent means IRS CI is investigating. A grand jury subpoena means the Department of Justice is involved as well.
Can an employer be prosecuted for unfiled Forms 941 if the business could not afford the taxes?
Yes. Using withheld taxes to cover payroll, rent, or suppliers is a common fact pattern in § 7202 cases. Financial hardship is generally not a defense, because the withheld money never belonged to the business.
Does not filing affect a green card or citizenship application?
It can. Naturalization requires good moral character, and unfiled returns can count against it. A permanent resident who files as a nonresident may be presumed to have abandoned that status. Raise any unfiled years with tax and immigration counsel before you submit an application.

Where we handle Non-Filer Cases

All Whiteford offices handle this work.

Colorado

Denver

2128 West 32nd Avenue
Denver, CO 80211
(720) 419-1296
Delaware

Bethany Beach

26 N. Pennsylvania Avenue
Bethany Beach, DE 19930
(302) 829-3043
Delaware

Rehoboth Beach

18949 Coastal Highway
Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971
(302) 829-3043
Delaware

Wilmington

600 North King Street
Suite 300
Wilmington, DE 19801
(302) 337-5359
District of Columbia

Washington, DC

1717 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
Suite 1300
Washington, DC 20006
(202) 972-6503
Florida

West Palm Beach

222 Lakeview Avenue, Suite 1550
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 282-9850
Kentucky

Lexington

250 West Main Street, Suite 1800
Lexington, KY 40507
(859) 687-6700
Maryland

Baltimore

7 St Paul Street
Suite 1500
Baltimore, MD 21202
(410) 498-6815
Maryland

Columbia

8830 Stanford Boulevard
Suite 400
Columbia, MD 21045
(410) 431-1954
Maryland

Ocean City

7408 Coastal Highway
Ocean City, MD 21842
(302) 829-3043
Maryland

Rockville

111 Rockville Pike
Suite 800
Rockville, MD 20850
(410) 347-8730
Maryland

Towson

Towson Commons, Suite 300
One West Pennsylvania Avenue
Towson, MD 21204-5025
(443) 278-2191
New Jersey

Fairfield

375 Passaic Avenue
Suite 100
Fairfield, NJ 07004
(973) 227-5900
New York

New York

444 Madison Avenue
4th Floor
New York, NY 10022
(646) 618-8660
New York

White Plains

1025 Westchester Avenue, Suite 106
White Plains, NY 10604
(914) 580-9176
North Carolina

Charlotte

4064 Colony Road
Suite 315
Charlotte, NC 28211
(704) 368-3534
Pennsylvania

Pittsburgh

11 Stanwix Street
Suite 1400
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Virginia

Falls Church

3190 Fairview Park Drive
Suite 800
Falls Church, VA 22042
(703) 280-9260
Virginia

Richmond

Two James Center, 1021 E. Cary Street
Suite 2001
Richmond, VA 23219
(804) 485-1492
Virginia

Roanoke

10 S Jefferson Street
Suite 1110
Roanoke, VA 24011
(540) 759-3560
Virginia

Virginia Beach

249 Central Park Avenue
Suite 300-91
Virginia Beach, VA 23462
(757) 208-9512

What clients say

Mr. March picked up the phone immediately as I called… Even though we hadn't talked about compensation, I was more than willing to pay Mr. March for the sage legal counsel. Mr. March said no — in fact he was more than happy to hear my problems and offer a solution.
DT
Daniel T.
Whiteford Tax Defense was absolutely incredible when it came to assisting me with my case. From day one, they were always available to answer any questions that I had. I would highly recommend Michael March to assist you with any cases you may have.
SK
Shawn K.
I called and Mike answered my call. Mike answered every question I asked with honest advice. It was nice that he answered the phone with no phone call back needed or waiting for follow up. I will be asking Mike to represent me on Monday.
GA
Greg A.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Disclaimer

Contact Michael March